Monday, January 11, 2010

EA's Miss

After the bell today, EA announced a massive miss for their fiscal year, reducing revenue and earnings per share expectations. CFO Eric Brown also said in a conference call that they expect the packaged goods business to be flat to down for Fiscal 2011.
For anyone paying attention to the larger trends in the video game market, this could hardly have come as a surprise. A few days ago, Gamestop, a key packaged goods distributor for EA, announced a similar miss. While Activision was setting sales records with Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2, EA had no major hits -- although, in fairness the COD:MW2 revenue was probably just filling in a sinkhole at Activision created by a music game business that has fallen off a cliff. EA is in the wrong business, with the wrong cost structure and the wrong team, but somehow they seem to think that it is going to be a smooth, two-year transition from packaged goods to digital. Think again.
John Riccitiello, the EA CEO, took over the reins of the company almost exactly 3 years ago. I was a senior executive at EA just prior to JR's return, and had a number of conversations with then-CEO Larry Probst about strategy at that time. As those who follow my blog know, I believed that the video game business had experienced a sea-change beginning in 2004, one that required immediate and decisive action.
My argument to Probst in February of 2007 was to reduce expenses immediately by a minimum of $200MM annually by reducing headcount and cutting back on ridiculous expenditures on risky titles (during my tenure, Spore and Godfather budgets had ballooned to ridiculous levels, and even spending on middle of the road products like The Simpsons and Superman had reached appalling heights). Meanwhile, I advocated hyper-aggressive R&D investment and acquisitions in a transition to digital distribution and games-as-service; combined with an approach to Wall Street that would position EA as a smaller but significantly more profitable company in the near term, with substantially improved long-term prospects when the digital future arrived.
This suggestion was derided by EA execs at the time -- they literally couldn't imagine going to Wall Street with a message of increased profitability rather than top-line revenue growth. They wanted to make the transition to digital while continuing to grow the packaged goods business. Ironically, they saw their looming innovator's dilemma as clearly as any company in the video game business back in 2006. They just weren't bold enough to act on that knowledge.
The old EA model was a basically a three-legged stool: 1) a profitable, recurring sports business (Madden, FIFA); 2) franchise games that produced big hits on a less frequent basis (The Sims, Need for Speed, Command & Conquer); and 3) a collection of digital assets (e.g.: Pogo & JAMDAT, and now Playfish) and distribution/partnership titles (e.g.: Rock Band & Left 4 Dead). Of those, the only stool leg left intact is the third one. Without the digital assets and the EA Distribution titles, they'd be in even more serious hot water.
EA's sports business has been hamstrung by vastly increased licensing costs (as I've discussed before) and failure to transition to a subscription/variable pricing model. This has substantially reduced the profitability of a business that EA used to rely on to fund other, riskier bets.
But by far the greatest failure of Riccitiello's strategy has been the EA Games division. JR bet his tenure on EA's ability to "grow their way through the transition" to digital/online with hit packaged goods titles. They honestly believed that they had a decade to make this transition (I think it's more like 2-3 years). Since the recurring-revenue sports titles were already "booked" (i.e., fully accounted for in the Wall Street estimates) it fell to EA Games to make hits that could move the needle. It's been a very ugly scene, indeed. From Spore, to Dead Space, to Mirror's Edge, to Need for Speed: Undercover, it's been one expensive commercial disappointment for EA Games after another. Not to mention the shut-down of Pandemic, half of the justification for EA's $850MM acquisition of Bioware-Pandemic. And don't think that Dante's Inferno, or Knights of the Old Republic, is going to make it all better. It's a bankrupt strategy.
So now, a couple of months after the board granted JR another $7 million worth of restricted stock units in addition to 140,000 options and EA Games president Frank Gibeau another $2 million in RSU's, EA cuts financial estimates to the bone. And don't believe this is the end of the bleeding. This latest stock drop, if consistent with the after-hours trading, will wipe out virtually all of the gain from 2009. Unfortunately, the loss comes after one of my favorite EA execs, business warrior John Schappert, returned from Microsoft to take over as COO and started firing 15% of the workforce to reduce costs.
With EA's enterprise value down below $4 billion, it's remarkable that nobody has stepped in to put them out of their misery with an acquisition. Certainly, Disney has been looking at them since I was at the house of the mouse back in the early 90's. And there are Chinese companies, like TenCent, that could easily swallow EA whole.
It's equally amazing that the board continues to support the existing management team through this debacle. Since JR took over, the company has destroyed over $11 billion in market value. Certainly, some of that was the economy and the general erosion of value on NASDAQ, but Activision (the blue line below, vs. EA's red line) has experienced far milder effects from the recession:



It's remarkably hard to kill a company doing $4 billion in revenues. But with flat or down stock performance since Q3 2003, how long are the institutional investors going to continue to hope against hope for a turn-around?

841 comments:

«Oldest   ‹Older   801 – 841 of 841
Kamagra said...

The post that you have made is really appreciable...

Sildenafil Citrate said...

this is really one of the best thong that i have seen.

ukash said...

thanks admin

ukash said...

very nice shared

muslin backgrounds said...

I got what you mean , appreciate it for putting up. Woh I am glad to find this website through google.

Unknown said...

Excellent work ... This is a big information about this... So thank you very much ... You have a mind of great thought.thanks to share these details ...
women shoes atlanta

backdrops said...

This awesome blog is no doubt educating additionally factual. I have picked up many helpful tips out of it. I’d love to return over and over again. Thanks. backdrops

restaurants scotrun said...

bThat's a Great topis.. I really appreciate it.. I read your post..
I have got lot of information to read this topic..thanks for share me...

restaurants stroudsburg said...

It's a big problem for me.. But when i read this post..
It's become a solution of my problem..
I am very thankful to share this blog.. I hope you have more information about this blog.. So, Please share me.. Thanks..

vpillsgold said...

seo egitimi seo eklentileri seo fiyatları seo hizmeti seo hocası seo nedir seo programları seo teknikleri seo tools seo uzmanı sosyal medya teknoloji haberleri web tasarım seo webmaster wikipedia arama motoru optimizasyonu wordpress icin en iyi seo eklentisi wordpress seo v-pills yorumları v-pills zararları orjinal v-pills v-pills kullananlar v-pills yan etkileri v-pills şikayetleri panax yorumları panax nedir panax sipariş panax şikayetleri orjinal panax panax kullanıcı yorumları panax kullananlar panax yan etkileri panax faydaları panax icerigi dr mustafa eraslan panax siparişi kibarlı panax

Auto responder setup said...

Interesting layout on your blog. I really enjoyed reading it and also I will be back to read more in the future.

iPhone 5 Otterbox said...

It was amazing to read..

buy viagra online said...

Thanks for this great post..

Soda Machines said...

I like your ideas about and I hope in the future there can be more bright articles like this from you. Soda Machines

Neopoints said...

Thanks for this very useful info you have provided us. I will bookmark this for future reference and refer it to my friends. More power to your blog. Buy Neopoints Online | http://www.topmovietrailers.co.uk

frnksmth said...

This is really great information found here, Very interesting information.
I like this very interesting website.
buy silagra online

vpills said...

nce jobe he!

siragulshek said...

Fiesta Party Jumpers has a wide selection of party rentals to choose from including: tables, chairs, linnens, tents, jumpers, bouncers, water slides.Our inflatable party rentals range from sumo wrestling, boxing to t-ball we have many inflatable games to choose from.
Even upon delivery our drivers are equipped with a vacuum cleaner and cloth to make sure your jumper rental is in perfect condition.

yonja medikal said...

dewor the post Mitch & for the boldness to state what no one else would. Bets among the analyst I speak with are that John doesn't last the enw.

ukash said...

hdnxthank you for posting...finally someone tells it how it is. I knew I wasn't going crazy thinking this every day I came to workretd

ukash kart said...

yehdsGreat loved it, will be waiting for your future posts Thank you for sharingdhsıu

ukash satış said...

tedgGreat loved it, will be waiting for your future posts Thank you for sharinggduw

dexe said...

yehdGreat loved it, will be waiting for your future posts Thank you for sharingsgueı

dexe tarak said...

erdfgvIt's really great post,, I hope every one in future will adopt these information.. Thanksfsfsy

horkes said...

yeudhNice Post thanks for sharing itdgvwtuı

horlama said...

kfıehjNice Post thanks for sharing itgfyuo

e 101 said...

orlfkNice Post thanks for sharing iteuıeg

slim shot said...

gyurgklthank you for posting...finally someone tells it how it is. I knew I wasn't going crazy thinking this every day I came to workgvyeruıo

dokuzlu çay said...

kfjndthank you for posting...finally someone tells it how it is. I knew I wasn't going crazy thinking this every day I came to workgdyuqovf

dokuzlu çay said...

euhdukGreat info, you made some truly interesting points. I appreciate your wonderful effortgdywo

ömer coşkun said...

uedhjsGreat info, you made some truly interesting points. I appreciate your wonderful effortgfuıwo

sauna eşofmanı said...

uehdwfqreat info, you made some truly interesting points. I appreciate your wonderful efforgdywuo

sauna eşofman said...

oeıksreat info, you made some truly interesting points. I appreciate your wonderful efforhwobvgı

sauna eşofman said...

peodjreat info, you made some truly interesting points. I appreciate your wonderful efforwqfsg

sauna eşofmanı said...

oldkjsbreat info, you made some truly interesting points. I appreciate your wonderful effortgcywqo

nicer dicer said...

lkdhreat info, you made some truly interesting points. I appreciate your wonderful effortdfxwtyovrf

panax said...

wqesdreat info, you made some truly interesting points. I appreciate your wonderful effortldıskh

Anonymous said...

nice blog






need Medisoft billing software

Jeremy said...

The Tadapox tablets online square measure composed of 2 salts, Dapoxetine and Tadalafil. accustomed alter typical health issues in males, it dilates the blood vessels of the erectile organ and helps or not it's erect once stimulation is given. thus Tadapox tablets principally work on intensifying pleasure by serving to the person keep erect for a extended length and not let him climax too early.

Jeremy said...

Tadapox is associate oral medication wont to treat male impotence and disfunction (ED). It contains tadalafil twenty mg and dapoxetine sixty mg. Tadapox tablets online
provide a similar performance and results, however at a less expensive value than different branded counterparts offered within the market. With Tadapox, you'll simply overcome your sexual issues and luxuriate in love-making sessions for a protracted time.

Anonymous said...

Tadapox is associate oral medication accustomed treat male impotence and dysfunction (ED). It contains tadalafil twenty mg and dapoxetine sixty mg. Tadapox tablets online
provide identical performance and results, however at a less expensive value than alternative branded counterparts obtainable within the market. With Tadapox, you'll be able to simply overcome your sexual issues and revel in love-making sessions for an extended time.

«Oldest ‹Older   801 – 841 of 841   Newer› Newest»